Why does the sinus matter?
The maxillary sinus is the air space inside the upper jawbone; its floor sits just above the roots of the back teeth. After the teeth are extracted, the bone in this area resorbs from the ridge side while the sinus expands downward. The result: the bone height needed for an implant decreases.
A thin membrane lines the inner surface of the sinus: the Schneiderian membrane. All sinus lift procedures are built on lifting this membrane upward without tearing it and allowing new bone to form in the space created beneath it.
The open (lateral window) method: window, membrane, graft
In the open method, a small bone window is opened in the side (cheek-facing) wall of the sinus. Through this window the membrane is lifted under direct vision and the space created is filled with graft material. If the remaining bone is sufficient, the implant is placed in the same session; if it is very scarce, the graft is first allowed to mature and the implant is placed later.
The strength of this method is that it can provide a large amount of elevation. A systematic review reports 3-year survival of implants placed with the lateral approach at around 90%; details such as rough-surfaced implants and covering the window with a membrane influence the outcome (Pjetursson 2008).
The closed (internal) method: access through the implant site, osteotome
In the closed method, no separate window is opened. Access is gained through the site prepared for the implant itself. The site is prepared up to the sinus floor; then the floor is pushed upward by a few millimetres with an instrument called an osteotome. The membrane rises like a small dome, a small amount of graft is placed beneath it if needed, and the implant is usually placed in the same session.
This method requires a smaller surgical field. A systematic review reports 3-year survival of implants placed with the transalveolar (closed) technique at around 93%, notes that this rate is comparable to non-augmented sites, and that the complication rate is low (Tan 2008).
Which one, and when? Residual bone height
The key to the decision is the remaining bone height measured on the CBCT scan:
- If the remaining bone is a few millimetres short and only a limited elevation is needed, the closed method is usually sufficient; it is often planned together with a short implant.
- If very little bone remains and a large amount of elevation is needed, the open method is more predictable.
- The shape of the sinus, its septa and the thickness of the membrane also influence the decision.
This is not a "good versus bad" choice; both methods are well documented in the literature. The right method is the least invasive route the anatomy allows.
The magnetic mallet: findings from my thesis
In the closed method, the osteotome is traditionally advanced by hand, tapping with a small mallet. In my specialty thesis I investigated an alternative to this: a magnetic mallet that delivers the impact in a controlled way. In a randomized controlled trial of fourteen patients, comparing the two sides within the same mouth, discomfort during the procedure was significantly lower in the magnetic mallet group, while the difference in post-operative pain was significant only on some days of the first week (Fazeli 2019). This is a small but concrete step toward making the closed method more comfortable for the patient.
Healing and follow-up
With both methods there may be swelling and mild discomfort in the first days; with the closed method this is usually less, but individual experience varies. For a few weeks, simple rules such as not blowing the nose forcefully and keeping the mouth open when sneezing protect the membrane. Follow-up appointments and X-ray monitoring over time are standard with both methods.
Frequently asked questions
Is there less discomfort with the closed method?
Because the surgical field is smaller, discomfort is generally expected to be lower. But "zero" cannot be promised; everyone's experience is different.
What happens if the sinus membrane tears?
Small perforations are common and most can be managed. If necessary the procedure is postponed or the method is changed; this is not a "failure" but part of planning.
Is a graft used?
It varies by case. With the closed method, in some cases bone formation beneath the membrane can be expected even without using any graft.
This article is for general information and does not replace a clinical examination. Suitability of any approach can only be decided after examination and imaging.